Team Talk: 4 Characteristics of Successful Teams

Greet the team and introduce yourself. Thank the coaches for allowing you to share today.

I want to start today’s talk with a quick word association. What is the first thing that pops into your mind when you hear the words, “successful team?” (Allow several players to respond and ask them why that particular thought came to mind when thinking of a successful team.)

Today, we are going to take a few minutes to discuss four key characteristics of successful teams. To help us remember these four characteristics, we will use a key word in each characteristic that will eventually spell out the word “TEAM.” Hopefully, these will be helpful for you as you continue your season.

At the end of our talk, there will be an opportunity for you to ask questions and provide feedback on what we discussed today. Let’s jump right in, with the letter “T.”

Key Characteristic #1: Successful Teams Share a TEAM-FIRST Commitment.

Maybe you’ve heard the expressions, “teamwork makes the dream work” or “there’s no I in team.” They might sound cheesy, but there is some truth to these adages. Few things can derail a team’s success more than focusing on individual success above the good of the team.

Individual goals are great. They motivate us to work hard and improve. But sometimes, a player may need to lay aside their personal goals, play a different position, or run plays that showcase someone else. If a team is really committed to team-first success, then individual players will give their best effort in whatever role they are asked to fill, for the overall good of the team.

Perhaps no team in recent history has better demonstrated this team-first approach than the New England Patriots, who appeared in nine Super Bowls between 2001 and 2018, winning six! Much of the team’s success has been attributed to something known as “The Patriot Way.”

Former Patriot Rob Ninkovich describes “The Patriot Way” in the following way:

“The way that [Coach] Bill [Belichick] coaches his team [is to put] the team first, not selfish, doing what’s best for the team, putting the team’s goals in front of your own personal goals.” 1

Even Tom Brady, widely considered the greatest NFL quarterback of all time, embodied “The Patriot Way,” adjusting his game and laying his ego aside for the greater success of the team. In the end, the New England Patriots constructed one of the greatest dynasties in the history of sports. Successful teams share a TEAM-FIRST commitment.

The letter “E” is for “Eyes.”

Key Characteristic #2: Successful Teams Keep Their EYES On The Prize.

Talk to any successful athlete and you will quickly learn that to achieve success on the field, they have lived lives of extraordinary commitment, discipline, and sacrifice, always keeping their eyes on the prize and prioritizing long-term success over short-term gratification.

In high school, Peyton and Eli Manning could often be found on their high school football field throwing with their dad and older brother at 5:00 a.m.

As a teenager, Clint Dempsey, the all-time leading scorer for US Men’s Soccer, commuted three hours each way from his small town to train with a more competitive team in Dallas.

Serena Williams follows a strict diet and exercise regimen that has allowed her to excel at the highest level of women’s tennis for over two decades!

Each of these athletes, and other greats like them, understood the value of forgoing short-term reward for the greater satisfaction of reaching long-term goals.

What are some practical examples of ways that high school athletes can choose long-term success over instant gratification? (Allow several players to share their thoughts and discuss.)

A few examples are the following:

  • Diet/Exercise – To achieve optimum performance on the field, it is important to “fuel” your body with proper nutrition, not just “fill” it with whatever is tasty or convenient.
  • Sleep – Athletes require adequate rest to stay mentally and physically sharp. To be at your best, you may have to say “no” to some social opportunities, late night movies, video games, or mindlessly scrolling through your phone to get the rest you need to perform.
  • Social life – Social connection is a must for all people, especially high school students. But it will be super important that you consider who you spend your time with and what types of things you are doing. Many high school athletes have derailed their athletic careers by simply making poor choices in their social lives.
  • Academics – Sometimes, student-athletes place a disproportionate emphasis on the “athlete” part while neglecting the importance of being a “student.” Every team has eligibility requirements to be able to play, so it will be critically important that your academics remain a top priority.

To be a successful team will require that players keep their eyes on the prize and prioritize long-term goals over short-term instant gratification, often saying “no” to the good, to say “yes” to the best. It will mean occasionally “missing out” on what you think you want right now to achieve what you want more in the long run. If being a successful team is your goal, however, it will be worth it.

Ok, we’re halfway home. We have discussed “T,” a TEAM-FIRST commitment and “E,” keeping our EYES on the prize. The next letter is “A,” which brings us to our third key characteristic – ACCOUNTABILITY.

“Success comes from knowing that you did your best to become the best that you are capable of becoming.” John Wooden

Key Characteristic #3: Successful Teams Create a Culture of Mutual ACCOUNTABILITY.

Accountability means clearly defining standards and expectations for the team and then holding one another to those standards. Without good accountability, it will be impossible to maintain a team-first commitment or consistently keep our eyes on the prize

In 2008, legendary Duke basketball coach Mike Krzyzewski was asked to coach the US Men’s Olympic basketball team. Prior to the Olympics, Coach K gathered his players and had them define the standards for how the team would operate and what they hoped to achieve. He then told his players, “Once you establish the standards, I as the coach will make sure you live up to those standards.”

A few weeks later, Kobe Bryant deviated from those standards when he took several selfish, low-percentage shots in a game against Australia. At that point in his career, Kobe Bryant was a three-time NBA champion and one of the best players in NBA history. His resume and “mamba mentality” made him the “alpha” of the team, but even he was not above accountability.

Coach K met with Kobe and shared some video from the game, including several examples of questionable shots, and pointed out his teammates standing around and watching him on some drives to the basket. Krzyzewski told Bryant to his face that these were “[b.s.] shots.” Coach K added: “There has to be more movement.” And then he held his breath. Bryant looked at Krzyzewski and said, “I got it, Coach. I got it. Don’t worry about it. Sorry about that.”2 Two and a half weeks later, the United States basketball team won Olympic gold.

Accountability means lovingly bringing it to a teammate’s or coach’s attention when they fail to uphold team standards. It also means encouraging and motivating others to continue reaching for those standards when they face obstacles or adversity. Accountability does not need to be harsh, but it needs to be consistent and apply to everyone. We will all need help to maintain the focus and discipline to uphold team standards, and we all need support and encouragement to “get back in the saddle” when we fail to do so.

Alright, so we have “T,” a TEAM-FIRST commitment, “E,” EYES on the prize, and “A” for ACCOUNTABILITY. The final key characteristic begins with an “M.” It’s our “MINDSET,” specifically, a growth mindset.

Key Characteristic #4: Successful Teams Embrace a Growth MINDSET.

At the beginning of our talk, I asked you what first came to mind when you heard the words, “successful team.” (Feel free to modify this portion to reflect the discussion at the beginning of the talk.) Many of the things we came up with, and many of the teams that we have been talking about, centered around tremendous winning records, but being “successful” is about so much more than winning games.

At the end of the year, only one team will be crowned champions. Does that mean that every other team is “unsuccessful?” No way! There are many ways to measure success, even if you don’t take home the title.

Successful teams operate with something called a growth mindset. Author and psychiatrist Carol Dweck differentiates between what she calls a “fixed mindset” and a “growth mindset.” A fixed mindset believes we are born with a certain set of skills and abilities. It emphasizes results, and the goal is to minimize failures and setbacks, because each one exposes a flaw in our “fixed” ability.

A growth mindset, on the other hand, believes that skills can be learned, and abilities can be developed through practice and hard work. The emphasis is on the process more than the outcome, and setbacks are viewed as opportunities to grow.4 In the growth mindset, there is always room for improvement and failure is never fatal, because failure can teach us and set us up for future success!

John Wooden led the UCLA Bruins men’s basketball team to an incredible 10 national championships in 12 years and is widely considered one of the greatest coaches of all-time. Listen to this quote from Coach Wooden:

“Success comes from knowing that you did your best to become the best that you are capable of becoming.”5

Clearly, Coach Wooden understood and embraced the growth mindset, and his teams experienced great success on the court and in life, as they continued to take risks, seek out challenges, and embrace setbacks as opportunities to grow.

In the growth mindset, there is always room for improvement and failure is never fatal, because failure can teach us and set us up for future success!

Wrap Up

To recap, we’ve talked about four characteristics of successful teams today:

  1. T: Successful teams share a TEAM-FIRST commitment.
  2. E: Successful teams keep their EYES on the prize.
  3. A: Successful teams create a culture of mutual ACCOUNTABILITY.
  4. M: Successful teams embrace a growth MINDSET.

Thank you so much for giving me your time and attention today. I want to take just a few minutes to answer any questions you might have. (Allow players/coaches to ask questions.)

I do have just one favor to ask. We’re going to pass out some brief comment cards. We would love it if you could take about two minutes to give us some honest feedback about the talk today. It is always helpful for us to know what students find most helpful, as well as what topics you might be interested in hearing about.

I also want to invite you to another, voluntary event we will be having (insert event details here). You see, we believe that people are three dimensional, meaning that they have a physical component, a mental component, and a spiritual component. We also believe that to be the very best version of yourself on the field and in life, it’s important to care for all three dimensions of our lives.

Cru is an organization that supports students who are interested in developing the spiritual side of their lives. Addi (Cru student leader) has been involved for the past four years; she and our Cru staff team would love to talk to anyone who is interested in hearing a bit more about Cru and how we seek to serve students in our community. If anyone is interested, we will (insert event details here) and share a little bit more about Cru and how our faith can help us to be more successful on and off the field.

There is a place on the card where you can provide your contact information if you would like a reminder text about this event. Thanks, guys/ladies. Best of luck on the remainder of your season.

Next Step

Prepare and use this talk as part of a team talk strategy for your campus.

Team Talk Strategy

RECENT POSTS

The Reach Your School Playbook
A simple, step-by-step guide to help students, and the adults who support them, start and grow a movement to reach their school.
Comment Cards 101: Capture Interest, Build Relationships
A simple guide to using comment cards to capture student interest, build relationships, and follow up effectively after any event.
Student Leader Application and Covenant
Two optional documents to help you identify, prepare, and support student leaders with clarity and consistency.
The Reach Your School Playbook

You want to make a difference at your school. You care about your friends. You see the need. You’ve probably even thought, “Someone should do something.”

What if that someone is you?

The Reach Your School Playbook was created to help students take that step, and to give adults a simple way to support them along the way.

Made for Students, Helpful for Adults

This Playbook is designed first for students. It helps you take ownership, lead your friends, and build something that actually reaches your school.

At the same time, if you’re an adult, youth leader, parent, or volunteer, this gives you a clear way to come alongside students without taking over.

  • Students lead
  • Adults support
  • Everyone moves forward together

Why Most People Don’t Start

A lot of students never take the first step. Not because they don’t care, but because they feel stuck.

  • “Where do I even begin?”
  • “What if no one shows up?”
  • “How do I get others involved?”

Uncertainty can keep people from moving. This Playbook breaks that barrier. It gives you a clear path so you can stop overthinking and start doing.

What This Helps You Do

This isn’t just ideas sitting on a page. It’s a practical guide you can actually use right now.

With the Playbook, you can:

  • Start something meaningful, even if you’re on your own
  • Gather a few friends and build momentum
  • Share your faith in natural, real ways
  • Lead with confidence, even if you’ve never led before
  • Build something that lasts beyond you

You don’t have to have it all figured out. You just need a place to start.

“Start where you are, use what you have, take the first step.”

A Simple Path to Follow

The Playbook walks you through five clear steps. Each one is simple, practical, and designed to help you take action.

  • DREAM: Start with a vision for your school and what God could do there
  • PRAY: Learn how to pray for your campus in real, meaningful ways
  • GO: Take action, gather a team, and begin reaching people
  • GROW: Build a group that develops leaders and multiplies
  • SEND: Help others step out and reach their friends too

You don’t have to guess what to do next. It’s right there in front of you.

Built to Be Used, Not Just Read

This isn’t a long manual you’ll never finish. It’s short. It’s simple. It’s designed to move you forward.

  • Easy to read
  • Clear next steps
  • Real examples
  • Space to think and act

You can go through it on your own, or walk through it with a couple of friends. Adults can use it to guide conversations and help students take ownership.

You Don’t Have to Do This Alone

Starting something can feel intimidating. But you’re not on your own. The Playbook connects you to tools, coaching, and a bigger movement of people who are doing the same thing. Take one step, and you’ll find support along the way.

Start Today

You don’t need a perfect plan. You just need a first step.

Next Step
Download the Playbook with the button above and walk through the first section this week with a friend!
Comment Cards 101: Capture Interest, Build Relationships

Why Comment Cards Matter

The most important thing you do in ministry isn’t running events, it’s building relationships. Big gatherings are great, but they aren’t personal. Comment cards help you bridge that gap. They give students a simple way to raise their hand and say:

  • “I’m interested”
  • “I want to get involved”
  • “I want to talk”
  • “I made a decision”

A comment card is more than a form. It’s a filter. The event gathers the crowd, but the comment cards reveal the ones who are ready. Instead of guessing who’s interested, students tell you. And that’s what allows you to follow up personally and meaningfully.

Download Comment Cards

Physical vs. Digital Comment Cards

You can collect information digitally, but physical cards still win.

Physical Cards

  • Higher response rate
  • Easier to complete in the moment
  • No distractions
  • Feels more intentional

Digital Options

  • Students are less likely to fill them out
  • Distractions
  • Technical glitches

Digital can work, but many ministries find they get about half the responses compared to physical cards. Even in a digital world, physical cards often get better results. If you want the most responses, go physical first.

“The card isn’t the win, the conversation is.”

How to Use Comment Cards

1. Pass Them Out at the Right Moment
Usually at the end of a meeting or outreach, when interest is highest.

2. Give Everyone a Pen or Pencil
Don’t assume students have one. They won’t.

3. Walk Through the Card Together
This is huge. Once everyone has a card, read each section out loud and guide them:

  • “Write your name here”
  • “Check this if you want to get involved”
  • “Check this if you prayed to receive Christ”

If you don’t do this, students rush through and check random boxes.

4. Give Them Time to Complete It
Pause. Let them actually fill it out.

5. Collect Them Immediately
Don’t leave it optional or vague.

Use Incentives to Increase Response

Want more cards turned in? Use prizes.

  • Gift cards
  • Snacks
  • Fast food coupons
  • Free merch

Tell them:
“Turn in your card, we’ll draw for prizes.”

It works. A simple prize can double your response rate.

Best Practices That Make a Big Difference

Use cardstock
Regular paper tears or gets ruined. Cardstock holds up better.

Keep it simple
Too many options overwhelm students.

Look through cards immediately
Scan for:

  • Students who want to get involved
  • Spiritual decisions
  • Urgent needs

If possible, connect with them before they leave the meeting. The best practice is to follow up within 24–48 hours. After that, interest fades fast. So if. you can talk with them before they leave and set up a time to connect again in the next day or so, you will get your best results.

Turning Cards Into Conversations

A comment card is just the beginning. The goal isn’t collecting information. The goal is connection. Use what they checked to guide your follow-up:

  • Grab lunch
  • Meet after school
  • Start a Bible study
  • Have a gospel conversation

Final Thought

Comment cards can feel like a small detail, but they might be one of the most important things you do at an event. They help you move from a crowd, to a conversation, to a changed life.

Next Step
Download a comment card and use it at your next meeting.
Student Leader Application and Covenant

Strong student leadership doesn’t happen by accident.

Whether you’re a student leading your peers or an adult supporting a movement, clarity around leadership can make a huge difference. These simple documents are designed to help you communicate expectations, invite the right students in, and build a healthy leadership culture.

They’re optional tools for any campus movement, not requirements, but many teams find them incredibly helpful.

Student Leadership Application

This application is a simple way for students to express interest in leadership and for you to get to know them better. It creates space for students to share their story, their faith, and why they want to lead. It also helps ensure they understand the purpose and message of your ministry before stepping into a leadership role.

Leaders often use this as a starting point for conversations, discernment, and development, not just as a form to collect.

Student Leadership (Editable Document)
Student Leadership Application (PDF)

“Great leadership starts with clarity, not assumptions.”

Model Student Covenant

This covenant helps define what it means to be a student leader in your group. It clearly communicates expectations, both in character and commitment, and gives students a chance to step in with understanding and ownership. Because it’s customizable, you can adapt it to fit your local context, adding practical expectations that make sense for your team.

Many leaders use this as part of training or onboarding, helping students not just say “yes” to leadership, but understand what they’re saying yes to.

Model Student Covenant (Editable Document)

Next Step
Review these documents and choose one to use with your leadership team this semester:

Share This Post

More to Explore